Help, It’s Up to Us…

When Brugnaro leaves, the task of dismantling "his" model of corporate and proprietary management of the Municipality and proposing a different one will remain. We need a lineup that is not only alternative in terms of programs and people, but which is a radical departure from the current management of the city and territory.
MARIO SANTI
Condividi
PDF

Versione Italiana – Translation by Paul Rosenberg

Recent events in Venice – a councilor arrested and the Mayor under investigation – fit well into the regression in the city’s ability to govern that has accompanied its progressive historical involution over the last fifty years.

Even after the fall of the “dominant” Republic, Venice was a lively city, territorially and economically diverse. In the last century it was still capable of being the functional unicum – economy and services – that has been articulated between cities on land (Marghera with its industrial production, Mestre and the metropolitan urban territory) and water (Venice and its islands).

However, in the last half century we have had a crisis that has affected the entire urban territory, first with the decline of industrial and artisan production and local trade, then with the aggression and upheaval that the tourist monoculture brought first to historic Venice, but now also to the mainland.

Without looking back with longing to the government of the Doge and the Grand Council, in the Seventies and Eighties we also had a Municipality that did many positive things (especially in the social area). It then devolved towards a use of the city increasingly centered on speculative income that is functional to that monoculture.

This is how we arrived at Brugnaro’s two terms as Mayor. The cost to the city will not only come from major works. Fortunately, not all of them were “brought home” in time (see the Pili deal, which will now be hard to close…). But yes, there have been choices that have left their mark. The selloffs of buildings that become hotels despite the resolution that prohibits new hotels, “except for exceptions”, which seem to always get pulled out of the hat. There is also the unwillingness to regulate short-term rentals, despite Venice having been in a position to do so for two years, with the result of having destroyed both the residential and the student housing market.

These two examples make it clear that the Mayor, first and foremost a speculator, has been a standard-bearer of laissez faire – the non-government that lets the market act on its own. His administration was unable to stem the dynamics in progress (despite the fact that urban planning and administrative regulation also offer the Municipality some tools …), and instead directly encouraged them. It is not surprising then to discover that – in the murky and opaque framework of the management of the Municipality and its subsidiaries (which provide services to the city) – there are those who “take advantage of it”. And that a Boraso pops up, with his well-paid facilitations for friends.

Brugnaro will not fall. He has declared that he wants to continue to carry out his “work for the city”. In any case, we will go to the polls in a year at the latest. The question is whether there are forces for change which can transform the wave of indignation created by lifting the lid on the “corruption” that governed the Municipality into an alternative that involves programs but also the ways of managing public affairs.

Will this political, programmatic and ethical alternative be unambiguously embraced by political forces? Will it be able to gain the trust and support of citizens?

I entitled these observations “Help, It’s Up to Us …” because the ability to build this alternative does not seem simple or obvious to me.

First of all, we must not forget what authoritative exponents of Venetian society remind us. Perhaps passed off as unrepentant “grumblers”, when instead their role as “civic sentinels” should be recognized in a framework that easily tends towards political conformism. I am thinking, for example, of Andreina Zitelli’s reminder that many of the main choices made in the Municipality (in particular regarding the management of key problems for our territory, such as those that revolve around MoSE, the management of cruise ships, the protection of the Lagoon, and the role of Porto Marghera) were made with the substantial agreement of the main political forces – including the opposition and in particular with the Democratic Party: the break with power-sharing is therefore the first element that must be put in place, without which an alternative would not really be an alternative.

The second task is to overcome the sectarian and minority “vice” of the alternative candidates.

During the last municipal elections there was an attempt, started by associations and movements and later engaged by political forces, to promote a path towards “another possible city”. It started early, with large popular assemblies and in a climate of fruitful programmatic discussion, celebration and participation. However, when it came time to narrow down the choice of candidates, that sense of protecting their own spaces, which unfortunately is a historical characteristic of the forces that call themselves left-wing and/or alternative, re-emerged. That led to the counter-productive presentation of five separate lists that perhaps competed more with each other than with a right-wing that was capable of giving a sense of unity to the outside, also thanks to the role of undisputed dominus that Brugnaro had (at least until he started his failed attempt to create a list at a national level). Thus, we moved from a unitary idea that was capable of being a real alternative for governing the city to electing a handful of opposition representatives, who have been substantially without influence at this level, even though now they seem to have been put back in the game by their opponent’s mistakes.

I want to say this very clearly.

Over these past few years, if members of civil society and movements in our territory needed “support in the Municipality” they went to talk to the “opposition councilors”, who in turn have felt fulfilled by this being sought by “civil society”. But the opposition has at most guaranteed them a query – most of the time left unanswered – or a speech at a Council session, without their proposals ever being given the necessary institutional hearing.

I don’t know if the majority will be able to reorganize for the next administrative election. The judiciary’s intervention has created the basis for questioning the “Brugnaro system”. In Venice, the right has dug a hole in the municipal institution’s credibility.

Will all of this lead to disaffection and a decline in voter turnout, or will it reawaken the ability to find content, faces and methods that can bring it up again? Will it be possible to put forward a convincing proposal that makes it clear that there is another way to govern the city.

The first necessary choice is for all the “opposition” forces in the City Council to take a step back and make themselves available for a process to build unity, aiming for the participatory construction of a single list for the “regeneration of the Municipality”

I would like a Be. Bo. list, which could take the best of two great people that we have lost this year: the patient ability of Giovanni Benzoni to stitch together the construction of a program, and the radicalness of Stefano Boato regarding political choices about the issues facing the city and the Lagoon.

Then we can talk about programs at length. I have said many times in ytali that I think the magazine can open up (as it is already doing) to the debate.

But there is a choice ahead to be made. And that is to build these programs in a unified manner through a participatory process, at assemblies where everyone – movements, people, political forces – can express themselves, led and managed in such a way that ensures that everyone can speak and be heard.

A group of facilitators would be necessary, as well as defining a facilitation system that regulates the times and rules of the debate. In short, first define a method, then discuss the merits. So:

First the definition of the program. Then the discussion on how to choose the candidates, whether it be primaries, quotas linked to gender and/or to the groups promoting the path, or even the definition of a list of candidates for Mayor/Councilor from which to draw lots and/or perhaps rotate halfway through the mandate.

These are just hypotheses, to which others may be added…

Images ©Andrea Merola: From the protest of citizens gathered under and inside the Town Hall of Mestre, August 2, 2024

Back to YtaliGlobal

Help, It’s Up to Us… ultima modifica: 2024-08-28T19:06:18+02:00 da MARIO SANTI
Iscriviti alla newsletter di ytali.
Sostienici
DONA IL TUO 5 PER MILLE A YTALI
Aggiungi la tua firma e il codice fiscale 94097630274 nel riquadro SOSTEGNO DEGLI ENTI DEL TERZO SETTORE della tua dichiarazione dei redditi.
Grazie!

VAI AL PROSSIMO ARTICOLO:

POTREBBE INTERESSARTI ANCHE:

Lascia un commento