Making Better the Enemy of the Good

Opining about the nation "not being better than this" is, at best, an indirect questioning of the “goodness” of well over half the population – our neighbors, friends and co-workers – if not an outright insult to them.
PAUL ROSENBERG
Condividi
PDF

The news has been filled with reactions to the re-election of Donald Trump, largely emotional in nature, viz. declarations of elation and optimism on the winning side and a lot of expressions of doom and depression on the other. This is, of course, perfectly natural, as is the onslaught of blame and analyses claiming to explain why the election turned out the way it did. However, in the all too human struggle to “make sense” of things and define sides, some of the things being said in the losing camp are, to say the least, a distressing indicator of a certain self-regard (self-righteousness even?) that seems to fly in the face of the values and principles that the very people who are saying them think they represent.

For example, some have been saying things like “We’re not better than this” (“America needs to admit it’s not ‘better than this’“, or “Our mistake was to think we lived in a better country than we do“). This is deeply problematic, if not blindly delusional. “We”, as people and as a nation are exactly “this”, and always have been. The word “better”, in this context, is loaded with bias, judgement (in the most negative sense of the word) and even outright prejudice, because here “better” unavoidably translates to “better than people who think and vote differently than I/we do”. That is a profoundly undemocratic point of view to embrace, all the more so when it is done unthinkingly and reflexively, as is happening in the wake of this week’s election.

The question begs asking: better than whom, better than what? It strains comprehension to see people who consider themselves to be champions of freedom, equality, and even democracy talk this way. The fact that they do betrays a willful denial of the way things are, not only in the US, but around the world. Put less generously, it reeks of tribalism. Opining about the nation “not being better than this” is, at best, an indirect questioning of the “goodness” of well over half the population – our neighbors, friends and co-workers – if not an outright insult to them.

Facebook post screenshots

A truly plural society and real democracy means, by definition, freedom of thought and expression and acceptance of the majority’s will, as well as acceptance of the fact that disagreement and dissent are a permanent feature of human existence. We can never truly understand anyone else’s point of view, their deepest or even their shallowest motivations. Sure, in the US the cast of political characters has changed and demographics keep shifting, but humanity and its many often contradictory or inexplicable ways of thinking have not.

A similar argument can be made about the casual and ignorant way the word “fascist” was thrown around during the campaign. On one hand, Donald Trump routinely called Kamala Harris a fascist, a communist and a socialist, often in the same sentence, evidently ignorant of the fact that communism and fascism were diametrically and violently opposed to one another. But it’s the kind of swipe that everyone grew used to hearing from him, diluted in some way by its nonsensical contradiction. On the other hand, when Kamala Harris decided to begin calling Donald Trump a “fascist”, she said it like she knew what she was talking about. But did she, or anyone else for that matter, really know what it meant?

It is not a stretch to say that most Americans have little or even no idea what true fascism really is: a specific political ideology that was embodied by specific political leaders and parties in a specific geographical and historical context. On the other hand, it’s safe to say that people in Europe know what fascism really is. Their parents and they themselves lived through it and experienced it first-hand. American troops fought the Nazis, yes, but it was Europeans who fought against fascism, starting long before the outbreak of WWII.

One is not automatically a “fascist” because they espouse right-wing ideology. Perhaps it felt good to those who think they are “better” than him and his supporters to hear Donald Trump labeled in this way, but how far does this label extend? Are Republican voters fascists too? Thus, the careless use of the term was also a great discredit to Kamala Harris and her campaign, especially the way it was suddenly adopted as a “closing argument” in the last weeks of the campaign, further diminishing the word to a vapid label, just another schoolyard insult in a campaign filled with them, and diminishing the candidate herself in the process.

Meanwhile, the broader results of the election, especially in statewide elections, tells a much more nuanced story that defies quick explanations and easy labels.

Perhaps there is no better example than the result of the voting in North Carolina. Donald Trump won the state handily this time. Yet, the same pool of voters elected a state government that is strikingly made up of Democrats. Governor, Lt. Governor, Secretary of State, Attorney General, Superintendent of Public Education; North Carolinians elected Democrats to all of these offices this week. Furthermore, Republicans in the NC General Assembly lost the veto-proof supermajority they’ve enjoyed and exploited for twenty years because a Republican lost their re-election bid to a Democrat: not in a “safe” urban district, but in a more remote and supposedly “red” area. Of course, North Carolina is not the only place this happened. Montana sent Republicans to Washington, but added nine new Democrats to their statehouse, also breaking a long-standing Republican supermajority.

This phenomenon, which per force means there was a considerable overlap in people who voted for these Democrats and also voted for Donald Trump, seriously calls into question the view that America is completely polarized. Are things really so “black and white”, or “red vs. blue” or “conservative vs. liberal”? The results in NC and Montana (and now in Nevada) don’t just suggest otherwise, they insist on it. If American politics truly boiled down to the duality of Republican vs. Democrat, right vs. left, the results in the aforementioned elections, along with the approval of a swath of referendums in favor of abortion rights and against vouchers for charter schools in states around the country, would have cut directly along these lines. The reality is that they did not.

Democracy, and the “will of the people” are clearly far more complex than can be explained simply by polarization in the electorate and/or the media. Likewise, the millions of people who turned out and cast their votes in this election and – if not especially – their reasons for doing so are equally complicated, and clear explanations are just as elusive. However, the election results decisively discredit the notion of a clearly divided electorate, as well as the more pernicious proposition that some people and their opinions are “better” than others.

To espouse such a notion is to have ignored the facts, misused loaded terms, and slandered a great many people, and in doing so, allowed better be the enemy of the good.

Cover Image: Photo by Maria Thalassinou on Unsplash

Back to Ytali Global

Making Better the Enemy of the Good ultima modifica: 2024-11-09T21:52:40+01:00 da PAUL ROSENBERG
Iscriviti alla newsletter di ytali.
Sostienici
DONA IL TUO 5 PER MILLE A YTALI
Aggiungi la tua firma e il codice fiscale 94097630274 nel riquadro SOSTEGNO DEGLI ENTI DEL TERZO SETTORE della tua dichiarazione dei redditi.
Grazie!

VAI AL PROSSIMO ARTICOLO:

POTREBBE INTERESSARTI ANCHE:

Lascia un commento