
The United States seems to have entered a new phase in the transition from the acceptance of objectively measurable reality and fact to a denial of the same in favor of beliefs or preferences. Mass denial of phenomena from climate change to the result of the 2020 presidential election is now embedded in the system. There is a strong current that believes, in some cases quite aggressively, that it is indeed entitled its own facts, filtered and selected to create or reflect specific narratives of reality.
This kind of thinking is human and not new. Consider the writings of religious sects in the turbulent Kingdom of Israel around the time Jesus lived, when the Temple still stood and many groups fervently believed in a coming, if not immanent, divine battle between the forces of good and evil, light and darkness. Many ancient groups, prophets and orators railed against the establishment and its corruption. Some adopted extreme perspectives and split off from the rest of society to pursue radical forms of religious belief and practice. Religions and cultures vehemently and often violently denied interpretations and narratives of reality other than their own, and still do.
The phenomenon of denialism (defined as “the practice of denying the existence, truth, or validity of something despite proof or strong evidence that it is real, true, or valid” – Merriam Webster dictionary) has taken on an incredible weight in American political thinking. Its modern foundations were arguably laid down by climate change denialism, which was able to insidiously work its way into the mainstream by continuously questioning something which could not be definitively proven, but also by challenging unfavorable data as false and proactively producing other sets of data that built a different – and fictional – narrative of reality.

Then, of course, came election denialism, whose success was predicated on Donald Trump’s relentless insistence that the 2016 election was “rigged” throughout his campaign – which continued unabated after his election to the presidency. Thus in 2020 the idea that the election was going to be stolen was a cornerstone of the Republican campaign, and the conviction that the election was in fact stolen was turned into an article of faith – a required display of fealty for anyone who did not want to risk their neck.
On the other hand, Joe Biden did win that election, did take office, and ended up engaging in yet another form of denial, but this time about himself. Joe Biden denied his health problems to the nation until there were just 100 days left to muster a genuine campaign, which he was visibly and alarmingly unable to do. This denial had profound effects, misleading hopeful and trusting voters who didn’t want to believe the old fighter had really lost his swing, or worse, that he was denying the truth.
In hindsight it seems that Kamala Harris and her campaign were suspended in a kind of generalized state of denial for all of its 100 days. When Harris emerged at her triumphant post-debate rally in Greensboro, NC to a two minute long, deafening ovation, she looked around incredulously and then said, “I guess we’re really doing this!” to more deafening adulation. Charming as the moment was, the underlying current of disbelief that can be read into the statement, the sense of not really being prepared for what was happening to her, is now more tragically palpable. She was in no way prepared with a credible or compelling platform, and ran a campaign relentlessly focused on identity politics and in particular on certain types of women, accompanied by a dizzying – and to many utterly alienating – array of top female celebrities (for some women) whose opinion or support was worth less than the clicks and likes they generated on social media when it came to persuading anyone why they should vote for her.
Donald Trump, on the other hand, had been spelling out his agenda very clearly in a campaign that continued for nine years, while all the while denying everything. Just as an example, he claimed he had never read Project 2025, didn’t know any of the people involved, never heard of it, etc. Denial is standard protocol, lying the lingua franca, a sort of coded signal to those who understand that he is willing to play rough with the insults and language to freak out the media and lure them into obsessively covering his every utterance, but nevertheless he absolutely means what he says when it comes to saying what he will do.

This semantic jujitsu has created an ongoing game of “will he/won’t he” about Trump and his policy intentions that has itself opened a large space, evidently, for considerable parts of the population and the media to deny to themselves that Trump meant what he said about everything, and are accordingly surprised that the process of the promised transformation is already getting underway. If the exclamations of shock at Trump’s cabinet nominations, which include a Fox News reporter as Secretary of Defense and Matt Gaetz as Attorney General (hard to believe one could feel nostalgia for Jeff Sessions, but…), not to mention White nationalist Stephen Miller, are an accurate reflection, it seems like a lot of people voted for Trump imagining that somehow, he couldn’t really mean it. Others even professed the hope that this second term would be more “normal” and “professional”. This denial of Trump’s record is all the more jarring given that Trump is widely felt by his supporters to be a man of his word who will do what he says he will do.
Here we arrive at the most unsettling denialism of all: denial of fact. Disdain for facts, hostility to education and science, and an even more hostile rejection of “fact-based news media” is a cultural phenomenon that is arguably more radical than the beliefs and practices of those ancient ascetics who lived by the Dead Sea, preparing themselves for the Ultimate Battle. That world had few facts to work with and only early science. Some of them could be certainly called fringe groups and extremists, but they were not denying reality – they were only trying to explain it. The denial of fact itself in a world with unprecedented access to information is a subject that merits exploration in other settings. For our purposes, it is enough to recognize that it now counts among the many denials and forms of denialism playing important and now fundamental roles in our society.
Thus the nation, and for that matter much of the world, seems to have made a deliberate choice to reject the idea of measurable fact and observable reality in favor of belief and preference. However, it cannot be denied that one side has done an infinitely better job of viscerally and explicitly describing their version of reality and the fact that they intend to impose it, having spent decades mastering the tools and preparing the agenda and judicial landscape to do exactly that.


Aggiungi la tua firma e il codice fiscale 94097630274 nel riquadro SOSTEGNO DEGLI ENTI DEL TERZO SETTORE della tua dichiarazione dei redditi.
Grazie!

