American Inquisition

There are striking - and perhaps instructive - parallels between Gian Pietro Carafa, better known as Pope Paul IV in 1555, and Donald Trump
PAUL ROSENBERG
Condividi
PDF

Nobody can negotiate anything with the pontiff; he seems to lack common sense; he does not base his speeches on reasonable arguments unless by chance he is free from sympathies and biases, and then he indulges in childish and womanly flattery, with which he tries to gain consensus. […] For him his will is reason; he uses radical methods to the point of obstinacy; he very rarely accepts compromises with which to develop his vast projects; he is not always present to himself.1

– Imperial postmaster Giovanni Antonio von Taxis, in a letter about Pope Paul IV, October 26, 1555


A Historical Model for Trump

It can be useful, if not reflexive, to seek examples in history that resemble or seem to explain current events. During the 2024 US election campaign, for example, frequent recourse was made to Nazism, Fascism and Hitler to label and describe the agenda being presented by Donald Trump.

Despite, or perhaps precisely because of Hitler’s historical proximity and unique status as an ultimate evil figure, this association failed to persuade voters not to vote for him. In fact, the association is quite welcome to a considerable segment of Trump’s supporters.

The Trump agenda is weakly – and inaccurately – branded as an attack on ‘democracy’. However, this falls far from the truth. The attack, which is being executed with breathless speed and efficiency, is on the entire American system of government and law itself. Democracy is just an idea. The rapid beheading and gutting of whole sections of the US government coupled with the wild distortion and expansion of others has overturned reality in America. The system of checks and balances is gone, replaced by compliant Legislative and Judicial branches eager to advance the president’s agendas. Elections, long openly and aggressively manipulated by state governments, are now being set up for permanent party dominance – as has already been done in my state of North Carolina – at the explicit behest of the White House.

Meanwhile, violent and cruel prison camps are being built around the country and brown skinned people – including US and legally present citizens of other countries – are being rounded up by masked gunmen, ‘disappeared’ into an extra-judicial system with its own courts, jails, rules and a rapidly growing armed police force. The military is on the streets of major cities, with explicit plans for more.

This leads back to the need for some kind of historical figure to compare all this to. In this regard, I suggest that we must go back several centuries before the villains of the early twentieth century, to the year 1555 and the reign of Gian Pietro Carafa as Pope Paul IV, who was also the leader of the Roman Inquisition. His story bears an uncanny resemblance to events unfolding in the United States, requiring us to only substitute a few words (for example “immigrants” for “heretics” or “Democrats” for “imperials”) to be left with the striking impression that one is reading yesterday’s headlines. Given Paul IV’s great importance in world history, the parallel seems worth exploring.  

Pope Paul IV

A Separate Power Base and a Weak Opposition

To begin with, Carafa had founded his own religious order, the Theatines, which became very powerful and was in control of the newly formed Roman Holy Inquisition. In a double violation of normal protocols, Carafa secretly investigated his rivals and opponents, then used the information he had to spring surprise accusations of heresy in the conclave against candidates for the papacy that he opposed. Over time, the Inquisition moved from exercising veto power over certain candidates to ensuring that its own candidates prevailed. Ultimately this led to the election of Gian Pietro Carafa himself as Paul IV, despite powerful opposition and even the personal distaste of some who voted for him:

Once again, the emperor was forced to suffer a defeat and witness the elevation of one of his enemies to the tiara, demonstrating the success achieved by the Holy Office in undermining established political logic with the crowbar of accusations of heresy. A report of the Conclave di papa Paulo quarto attributed to the cardinals divisions’ the choice of a pontiff ‘who many of them hated almost to death, not because they and everyone else considered him to be good, but because it was universally believed that he had combined goodness with such great severity that no one thought they could fall into even the slightest error without punishment’.

Trump similarly arrived to power with a political movement and machinery all his own creation, which is called MAGA, itself a very dense ecosystem of propaganda, populist media, and political policy more extensive and powerful than Paul IV could have dreamed of. Trump was similarly loathed personally by many who supported him. Like Carafa with the Holy Office, Trump was able to impose MAGA’s will on the system and force out his opposition, and then install second-rate but compliant people in key positions, people who willingly parrot his line and execute his orders, and further undermine the system.

Meanwhile, the dismal state of Carafa’s opposition at the time, the pro-Habsburg party, was very much analogous to that of the US Democrats today (just substitute ‘political’ for ‘religious’):

it was precisely the existence of very different religious orientations within it that fractured the political unity of the pro-Habsburg party, which by then was completely disjointed and incapable of acting with any coherence. On the eve of the abdication of Charles V and the division of his dominions, moreover, with Germany’s religious fracture having been sanctioned by the Diet of Augsburg and any hope of a compromise with the reformed world now faded, that party was losing its very reason for being, while in Rome the intransigents were now able to deal the coup de grace to their adversaries.

An Agenda Years in the Making and Boundless Pomp

Much like Trump with Project 2025, Carafa took office with a detailed agenda that had already been spelled out decades earlier. Likewise, Paul IV became pope at an advanced age, and his questionable physical and mental acuity were known to everyone, including himself:

His awareness of his senility helps to explain the vehemence with which, after winning the tiara, he strove to implement the ambitious program already set out in the memorialaccio he sent to Rome in 1532. …his election, energetically procured by wielding the inquisitorial hammer against every rival, was none other than the ultimate result of a project that had been pursued for thirty years. However, the results of his reign, which ultimately descended into a sort of blind fanaticism from which the papal tiara seemed to remove all restraint… were disastrous…

The new pope set out to aggressively enforce his version of strict Catholic Orthodoxy on the entire population by policing people’s consciences with the Holy Inquisition. However, he was also determined to “make the papacy great again” with the biggest celebrations and the finest regalia and furnishings, the most sumptuous and luxurious of everything:

…he wanted a grandiose coronation on May 26, 1555, accompanied by ‘the most superb celebrations and banquets ever seen before’, to make clear to all how he would interpret the rank of Vicar of Christ on earth, and he gave instructions that court life be marked by a pomp befitting the supreme dignity of the Church… …If he had already lived ‘with great pomp’ as a cardinal, once he obtained the tiara there was no sign of grandeur that he was willing to forgo, whether in the opulence of the table, the pomp of his relatives, the nobility and attire of his courtiers, or the splendor of his apartments, where he wanted everything to be magnificent and regal.

The riches didn’t stop, of course, with the pope himself. Again, in another parallel with Trump today, Carafa aggressively enriched his own: “…showering his greedy relatives, who soon became “cardinals, dukes and marquises”, with honors, dignities, titles and prebends…”, and surrounded himself with crooked family members: “In directing state affairs, he chose to have his nephew Carlo Carafa at his side, a corrupt and blasphemous mercenary, a vicious and unscrupulous man, and a murderous brigand…”.

National Guard troops in Washington DC. Photo from Facebook

Anger, Fear, Intimidation and Prejudice

Yet, in spite of the waste and the nepotism and vanity, Pope Carafa was singularly able to get his way in everything, mainly by being incredibly quick to anger and instilling fear in everyone around him that he might turn the might of his inquisitorial powers against them. Like Trump centuries later, Gian Pietro Carafa furiously fought any resistance to his will, to the point that most felt it safer to quietly give him his way.

This pontiff – wrote Navagero – is choleric and hot-tempered by nature. He has an incredible gravity and grandeur in all his actions, and he truly seems born to rule. […] He is vehement in dealing with all affairs, so much so that he does not want anyone to contradict him and takes offense when anyone, no matter who they may be, opposes him… Therefore, everyone judges it best to yield to the simple word of His Holiness. He is vehement, as I said, in all his actions, but in the Inquisition he is extremely vehement, so that no greater offence can be done to him than to make recommendations to him about these investigations.

– Venetian Ambassador Bernardo Navagero, 1557

It is not hard to draw a comparison here with the ruling style of current US president Donald Trump, whose temper and recourse to threats and intimidation are amply documented on a daily basis.

Carafa and Trump have another thing in common – a deep hatred for certain categories of people. The newly elected pope, vicar of Christ on earth, not only immediately prosecuted and imprisoned countless archbishops, cardinals, bishops, friars and other important figures in the Church, but he also launched a military war against Spain, for what were ultimately utterly personal and deeply prejudiced reasons:

The primary cause of the war was judged to be an old hatred against the Spanish nation, and particularly against the emperor, because (as he told me) he knew him to be too greedy for what belongs to others… His Majesty and the Spanish nation were never spoken of without calling them heretics, schismatics and the cursed of God, seed of Jews and Marranos, scum of the world, deploring the misery of Italy, which was forced to serve such abject and vile people.

– Venetian Ambassador Bernardo Navagero, 1557

Meanwhile, here in America, Donald Trump has launched his own wars, mostly with trade policy and tariffs against other countries, but with military force against the local population – those he and his forces define as the ‘enemies within’. Identities and ideologies are being criminalized. ICE is becoming the American Inquisition, seizing people for looking like they might be from the wrong place or thinking the wrong thing. The US government is setting up a system of organized state terror and brutality based on identity and conscience, not on actions or law. Like the Holy Office once did, they have a growing network of spies and agents, informers and mercenaries working tirelessly to expand their target range – and get bigger headcounts.

The Ghetto in Rome. Photo by the author

A Lasting Legacy: Criminalizing Thought and Identity

So, as the prisons and detention centers get built and the roundups keep going on at Trump’s command here in the US, it’s important to recall one of the other major accomplishments that Pope Paul IV is known for – the creation of the Italian Jewish Ghettos. While it is true that Pope Carafa borrowed both the model and the name ghetto from the site established in Venice in 1516, what he created in Rome and other major Italian cities was something much different than the Venice Ghetto. He built a walled-in, gated space in a city where Jews had lived for many centuries and forced them all to sell their properties and move there. He stripped them of many rights and limited the types of work they could do to a narrow range of risky and sometimes even dangerous trades. The Italian ghettos were expressly created to humiliate and impoverish the Jews, and just as importantly, to create a space for forced evangelism and conversion to Christianity.

Pope Paul IV criminalized thought and identity in various ways, doling out punishment, deprivation and of course imprisonment and torture as he and the Holy Office saw fit.

What matters most, however, is that Carafa also managed to cement his legacy and permanently change the Roman Catholic Church in very fundamental ways, ensuring that much of his policy remained in place for centuries after his death. One need only consider that the Jewish Ghetto of Rome was still controlled by the papacy in 1870, when the papal states fell in the capture of Rome.

325 years is a long time indeed. The Trump administration is only seven months or so into this term. They arrived, like Gian Pietro Carafa did centuries ago, extremely well prepared to rapidly execute a transformational plan that attacks and subverts the system itself, wresting power from the deliberative to the repressive wing of the government, and laying the groundwork for a new America of their own making and design, meant to last for generations to come.

The historical example of Pope Paul IV, with its many uncanny echoes of Trump today, may well be instructive in preparing for what will happen in the years and decades to come, as the new American Inquisition sweeps away all that does not glitter with white and gold, and given the realistic admission that an antidote for the already drastically and pervasively poisoned system seems unlikely to materialize.

I. All citations in this article are taken from the book At the Origins of the Counter-Reformation: Giovanni Morone. Politics, Heresy and the Church in Sixteenth-Century Italy, by Massimo Firpo and Germano Maifreda, Brill, (publication forthcoming). Many thanks to the authors.

Back to Ytali Global

American Inquisition ultima modifica: 2025-08-16T21:37:53+02:00 da PAUL ROSENBERG
Iscriviti alla newsletter di ytali.
Sostienici
DONA IL TUO 5 PER MILLE A YTALI
Aggiungi la tua firma e il codice fiscale 94097630274 nel riquadro SOSTEGNO DEGLI ENTI DEL TERZO SETTORE della tua dichiarazione dei redditi.
Grazie!

VAI AL PROSSIMO ARTICOLO:

POTREBBE INTERESSARTI ANCHE:

Lascia un commento