It is not yet official, but everything suggests that the next administrative contest in the Municipality of Venice will see Andrea Martella, for the center-left, and Simone Venturini, for the center-right, facing off against each other. This is a challenge whose significance goes far beyond Venice, as clearly explained in the article by ytali Venice is back at the center of national politics.
Beyond the formalities taking place in Rome around the final choice of a candidate, it is striking that the center-right’s candidate in pectore has already launched his election campaign in perfect continuity with the rhetoric and methods of the last ten years. Not a hint about the city’s structural issues, not a word about a vision for Venice, about its economic, demographic, and cultural destiny. Nothing. The first statements concerned the birthplace of his opponent (Portogruaro) and his alleged investiture being “decided in Rome”.
It is a revealing start. Because when political debate is reduced to personal details, it means that there is not much else to say. And indeed, where could Venturini start? From the work of these ten years of administration?
That would be difficult terrain. There are too many unresolved issues, too many questionable choices, too many promises that have remained just that. Venturini is certainly no stranger to city government: five years as leader of the UDC in the City Council in support of Mayor Orsoni, eleven as a leading councilor in the Brugnaro administrations. With the latter, he shared policies, responsibilities, and priorities.
If he is now running for mayor, he cannot pretend there is a discontinuity that does not exist. What could he promise that he has not already achieved, given that he already had the power to do so? What alternative vision can he propose with respect to the political line embodied in recent years by Luigi Brugnaro?
But let’s analyze the results of eleven years as councilor.
Residence and social cohesion
Population data
The total population of the Municipality of Venice fell from 264,579 inhabitants in 2014 to 252,224 on December 31, 2024: a decrease of 12,355 residents in ten years (Ca’ Farsetti statistical office).
At the beginning of 2025, the decline continued: the lagoon area (historic center, islands, and coastline) went from 74,456 residents at the end of 2024 to 73,215, over two thousand fewer people in two years; in the same period, the municipality as a whole lost about 12,000 residents since 2015 (again, official data from Ca’ Farsetti).
The situation is even worse for the “water” municipalities:
- Between 1994 and 2024, insular Venice lost 32.78 percent of its residents; coastal Venice lost 21.16 percent (Vita) .
- Between 2011 and 2020, Venice Island list 13.21 percent of its population, far greater than the national and regional averages (which are essentially stable) (Vita).
In essence: in ten years under Venturini’s leadership, the demographic decline has not only continued, but in Venice it remains among the worst in Italy.

Housing, short-term rentals, and the right to housing
On the housing front, which falls within his remit as Councilor for residence and social cohesion, the figures are stark:
- On the island of Venice, four out of ten private homes are not occupied by residents; this figure has grown by 15 percent since 2011 (Vita).
- In 2023, only 12 percent of those entitled to social housing were allocated a residence; between 2021 and 2022, the figure fell to 9 percent, and between 2023 and 2024 to as low as 3.4 percent (Vita).
- According to the civic observatory Ocio, in 2024 no vacant public housing was actually recovered and reallocated, despite the ‘Housing Plan’ announced by the administration; over 500 allocations are promised between 2025-2026, but these remain largely insufficient to meet demand (Vita).
Meanwhile, the tourism market is absorbing increasingly large parts of the housing stock, to the extent that there are now more tourist beds than citizens:
- In 2023, tourist beds in the historic center exceeded the number of residents: 60,638 beds for tourists compared to 56,165 residents in the old city (Vita).
- Over the last ten years, tourist arrivals in insular Venice have grown by 46.87 percent, non-hotel accommodation by 224.46 percent, and non-hotel beds by 226.3 percent (Vita).
- A study cited by Corriere della Sera estimates that in the central areas of Rome and Venice, between 70 and 90 percent of depopulation is related to the intensification of short-term rentals on Airbnb; in Venice, about 21 percent of residential apartments in central areas are used for short-term tourist rentals (Corriere della Sera).
Despite this situation:
- The so-called ‘Pellicani Amendment’ of 2022 gives the municipality the power to regulate short-term tourist rentals, but nothing has been done, except for presenting a draft regulation that is completely inadequate, only to then shelve it and give up on taking action.
These elements allow for very clear political criticism:
Since 2020, Venturini has been in charge of both housing and tourism policies (the latter also as a department head for the last six years, the former for eleven), which are precisely the two fronts from which the housing crisis stems. The numbers speak clearly about what Venturini as not done:
- he has not reduced the imbalance between beds for tourists and homes for residents;
- he has not used the regulatory tools available to curb the conversion of housing into short-term rentals;
- he has not brought public and social housing to a level sufficient to offset market pressure; on the contrary, the decade 2015-2024 is the only one in the last thirty years in which the municipal housing stock has not only failed to increase, but has actually decreased (Ocio).

Tourism
Strictly from the perspective of tourism, the ‘quantitative’ results are indisputable:
- In 2024, Venice recorded 5,876,797 arrivals and 13,290,937 overnight stays, exceeding the 12.95 million overnight stays recorded in 2019, which was already a record year before the pandemic (Regional statistical system).
- In its chapter dedicated to the fifty most popular Italian municipalities for tourism, ISTAT indicates approximately 13.3 million overnight stays in Venice in 2024, making it one of the country’s main tourist hubs (Istat).
However, the composition of tourism is the crux of the matter:
- In the historic center, overnight stays in non-hotel accommodations exceeded those in hotels for the first time: in 2024, hotels recorded around 4.5 million overnight stays (down from 5 million in 2019), while private accommodation reached 4.879 million, a 10.8 percent increase over 2023 and well above 2019 levels (Regional statistical system).
- At the same time, a platform that analyzes Airbnb reports 7,664 active listings in Venice in 2024, with a median occupancy rate of 76 percent and typical revenues of around €40,000 per year per host, a sign of a very profitable business compared to residential rentals (airbtics).
- The analysis “The invisible crisis of Venice” summarizes the result as follows: the city of water now has more tourist beds than residents and has seen impressive growth in non-hotel accommodation over the last decade (Vita).
From a political point of view, this makes it possible to render a clear judgment: Venturini pursued and accepted a model of tourism growth based on volume, with a very strong push towards non-hotel accommodation, without managing to build a true model of “sustainable tourism” that would protect permanent residence. The measures adopted, such as the access fee, did not prevent the current situation from arising; on the contrary.
Employment and economic development
Simone Venturini is Councilor for employment and economic development, but there are no clear signs of a revival in youth employment or local entrepreneurship: on the contrary, many young Venetians struggle to find stable jobs, resorting to precarious or seasonal work in tourism.
Here is a sample of the regional numbers: in 2023, there were approximately 98,000 unemployed people in Veneto (4.3 percent) (Confapitreviso). In Venice and on the mainland, recent estimates indicate unemployment rates slightly above the regional average due to economic specialization. Furthermore, the only sector experiencing strong growth is the hospitality industry (hotels and short-term rentals), as noted by local studies (vez.news).
Social policies, local healthcare, and services for residents
In terms of social spending, the budget data shows that:
- In the 2025 budget, the Municipality of Venice allocated approximately €114.8 million to social policies, equal to 13.76 percent of current expenditure; 1.39 percent went to tourism, 0.33 percent to economic development, and 0.08 percent to employment and vocational training (openbilancio.comune).
- According to a CGIL analysis of the 2019-2023 budgets, in the same period, revenue from additional IRPEF (personal income tax) rose from €57.1 million to €69.8 million, IMU (property tax) from €101.7 million to €106.1 million, and tourist taxes rose from €38.2 million to €47.4 million.
- The reduction in debt is also due to these higher revenues and the containment of personnel and service costs (CGIL.venezia).
At the same time, in terms of health and education services in Venice, there has been closures or downsizing of facilities over the years and great difficulty in securing general practitioners and pediatricians. Despite recruitment campaigns with incentives, citizens continue to protest the lack of primary care and problems with emergency services on the islands (Vita).
In terms of schools, the number of comprehensive schools in the city has fallen from eight to five; the school population is declining and many schools operate with ‘small classes’ or multi-grade classes, a sign of a system on the verge of sustainability, with parents and administrators forced to fight every year to avoid closures (Vita).
Although healthcare and education are primarily regional and state responsibilities, the delegation of social cohesion implies a political responsibility to defend and integrate these services. The picture that emerges is one where defending these sectors is often entrusted to grassroots mobilization, while the administration has chosen to focus on more ‘image-conscious’ measures (cultural projects, small local welfare interventions) that do not resolve structural critical issues (Vita).

This is the outcome of ten years of Simone Venturini’s work. But that is not the end of the story.
There is a much more significant political element: the organic link between Simone Venturini and Luigi Brugnaro. This link is neither episodic nor merely personal, but structural. Venturini was an integral part of Brugnaro’s government; he shared its approach, language, and priorities. This is not simply a matter of administrative continuity, but of continuity of vision—or, if you prefer, of method.
Brugnaro, due to regulatory provisions, cannot run for re-election today. But the law does not dissolve networks of relationships, nor does it erase interests consolidated over a decade. In politics, the problem is never just formal: it is substantial. Who decides? Who guides? Who really directs the strategic choices of a complex city like Venice?
In this context, Venturini’s candidacy appears to be the most straightforward solution to ensure a smooth continuation of the current structure.
Thus, the question becomes inevitable: is this what Venice needs? Management that continues by inertia, in which the successor is the natural extension of his predecessor? Or is a change needed, a paradigm shift, to an administration capable of taking responsibility for new choices and addressing the unresolved issues that have remained so in recent years?


Aggiungi la tua firma e il codice fiscale 94097630274 nel riquadro SOSTEGNO DEGLI ENTI DEL TERZO SETTORE della tua dichiarazione dei redditi.
Grazie!

